Should You Buy Two Mouthguards and Keep a Spare
Athletes often underestimate how quickly a primary mouthguard can fail during high-intensity training. Whether it’s a cracked custom-fit guard or a misplaced boil-and-bite, the loss of protective gear disrupts your schedule. While casual players might manage with one, those engaged in contact sports or frequent training sessions benefit from the redundancy of a spare. It’s a low-cost insurance policy for your dental health and your training consistency.
Quick facts
| Feature | Primary Guard | Spare Guard |
|---|---|---|
| Usage | Daily | Emergency only |
| Storage | Ventilated case | Sealed, cool area |
| Lifespan | 6–12 months | 18–24 months |
| Cost | Full price | Bulk discount |
How often do mouthguards typically need to be replaced due to wear and tear?
Mouthguards typically require replacement every 6 to 12 months for active athletes. Heavy grinders or those with high-impact training sessions may notice material thinning or loss of shape much sooner. Regular inspection for bite-through marks or jagged edges is necessary to maintain the intended level of shock absorption.
What are the primary factors that cause a mouthguard to become damaged or ineffective?
Several environmental and physical stressors contribute to the premature breakdown of protective dental materials.
- Bruxism: Persistent nocturnal or daytime grinding exerts constant pressure that thins the material and compromises its structural integrity.
- Temperature: Leaving guards in direct sunlight or near heaters causes the thermoplastic to warp, rendering the custom fit useless.
- Saliva: Exposure to acidic oral environments over long periods can weaken the chemical bonds within the plastic, leading to brittleness.
- Bacteria: Microorganisms trapped in the porous surface of the guard produce biofilms that degrade the material and cause foul odors.
How should a spare mouthguard be stored to ensure it remains hygienic and in good condition?
Keep your spare mouthguard in a clean, dry, and rigid container to prevent physical distortion. Avoid leaving it in a damp environment, as moisture encourages bacterial growth and can lead to unpleasant odors or mold. A small, ventilated hard-shell case stored in a drawer or a dedicated locker compartment is ideal.
One effective method is to place a small desiccant packet inside the case to absorb residual humidity. The main exception to this rule involves custom-fitted guards made of specific laminated materials; these can sometimes become brittle if they dry out completely for months on end. In those rare cases, a light rinse with cool, filtered water every few months helps maintain the material's flexibility without promoting bacterial colonization.
Are there specific types of mouthguards that are more prone to degradation over time?
Certain materials used in mouthguard fabrication are inherently more susceptible to chemical and physical breakdown than others.
- Boil-and-bite: These mass-produced guards often use thinner plastics that lose their shape quickly under the stress of heavy occlusion.
- Ethylene-vinyl acetate: While common for its comfort, this material is highly porous and absorbs fluids, which accelerates degradation over time.
- Two-layer: Guards with a soft inner layer and a hard outer shell often experience delamination where the two materials meet.
- Custom-laminated: These high-end guards are durable but can suffer from structural fatigue if the bonding agent fails during intense use.
What is the recommended protocol for cleaning and sanitizing a mouthguard to extend its lifespan?
Cleaning your guard after every use prevents the buildup of plaque and calcium deposits that degrade the plastic. Use a soft-bristled toothbrush and cool water to scrub the surfaces gently.
| Cleaning Agent | Frequency | Soak Time |
|---|---|---|
| Mild soap | Daily | 0 minutes |
| Distilled water | Weekly | 10 minutes |
| Denture tablet | Monthly | 15 minutes |
Applying these methods consistently makes sure that you remove harmful biofilms before they permanently etch the surface of your guard.
Does having a backup mouthguard provide a significant advantage for athletes who travel frequently?
Yes, traveling athletes benefit from having a backup because local supply options are often limited or expensive. Carrying a spare makes sure you don't miss a competition or training session if your primary guard is lost at an airport or hotel. It provides a reliable safety net during transit.
How can you determine if a mouthguard has reached the end of its functional life?
You can identify the end of a mouthguard's life by checking for physical deformation or a loose fit. If the guard no longer snaps firmly onto your teeth or feels like it slides around during movement, it is no longer providing adequate protection. Look closely at the occlusal surface for thinning areas or holes, which indicate that the material has reached its limit of shock absorption.
One clear sign is the presence of deep grooves or sharp edges that irritate your gums or tongue. An exception occurs with custom professional guards, which may appear slightly worn but still retain their protective thickness; if you are unsure, a dentist can measure the material thickness. If the guard shows significant discoloration or a persistent odor that remains after cleaning, the material has likely become too porous to remain sanitary.
Mistakes to avoid
- Storing in the car. Heat causes plastic degradation and warping, so keep your spare in a climate-controlled room instead.
- Ignoring the fit. A spare that hasn't been molded or fitted correctly provides little protection, so prep both guards before you need them.
- Sharing with teammates. Never swap guards even in an emergency, as this spreads bacteria and increases the risk of oral infections.
Is it cost-effective to purchase multiple mouthguards at once compared to buying them individually as needed?
Buying in bulk often lowers the unit price by 15% to 25%, making it a smart financial choice for long-term users. This strategy reduces the shipping costs associated with frequent, smaller orders.
| Purchase Quantity | Price Per Unit | Total Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Single guard | $50 | $0 |
| Two-pack | $42 | $16 |
| Three-pack | $38 | $36 |
Use these numbers to calculate your annual expenditure and determine if the bulk discount outweighs the risk of the spare guard aging in storage.
Managing Your Protective Gear
Investing in a second mouthguard allows you to rotate your gear and maintain a backup for unexpected losses. Keep your spare in a clean, dry environment to make sure it stays ready for immediate use whenever your primary guard fails.